Thursday, October 16, 2014

A courageous APOLITICAL act

On Sunday October 5, 2014 in a courageous apolitical act, Dr Claudia Escobar resigned and denounced the corruption in the Guatemalan judiciary system.

Not interested or involved in politics
This post is off topic, but it is of very dearly personal interest to me and I appreciate you the reader for taking a couple of minutes to read through.
Oscar Escobar

   This is one of the very few articles in English about the current judiciary system crisis in Guatemala highlighted by Claudia Escobar (My cousin!) and what's at stake.
It is from the The Canal, a blog from THE PANAMPOST.

La versión en español de este artículo se encuentra aquí:

Batalla por tribunales de Guatemala pone en juego a la democracia

Democracy at Stake in Battle for Guatemala’s Courts

Judge Escobar Mejía's Voice at the Forefront of Weeding Out Corruption

By Luis Eduardo Barrueto+
Guatemala's recently elected Appeals Court judge, Claudia Escobar Mejía, resigned her port and denounced corrupt election practices that favor the ruling party.
Guatemala’s recently elected Appeals Court judge, Claudia Escobar Mejía, resigned her post and denounced corrupt election practices that favor the ruling party. (Diario Digital)
Claudia Escobar Mejía, a recently elected magistrate to the Appeals Courts in Guatemala, stirred up the country on October 5 by resigning her post and publicly denouncing irregularities in the election process that favored the ruling party. What was brought to light as an unusually corrupt compromise — even for local standards — wouldn’t have captured national attention if not for her clear, denouncing voice.+
Her brave act has triggered public opinion and legal action, and is now awaiting the Constitutional Court’s resolution, on which the future of democracy in Guatemala depends.+
A few years ago, the Postulation Commission reformed the election process by introducing an attempt to make the election more transparent, and to further the inclusion of allegedly apolitical groups, including practicing lawyers and universities.+
Anyone with the official requirements can apply for the job. The 34-member commission then selects 26 semi-finalists, from which Congress will pick the 13 judges to be granted a seat at the Supreme Court, as well as other lesser appointments. These magistrates effectively become the leaders of the judicial system for a period of five years. Not subject to an effective system of checks and balances, they are, in fact, the men at the steering wheel of a country that’s only been a formal democracy since 1985.+
Several media outlets and journalists brought to light an unusual agreement between the ruling Patriotic Party (PP), and the main opposition party, Renewed Democratic Liberty (LIDER), to influence the outcome of the election by recommending members of the Postulation Commission who to nominate.+
Formerly antagonists, PP party leaders improvised an alliance with LIDER due to the untimely breakup of a previous pact of three parties, which had proved useful in the election of representatives to the Supreme Electoral Tribunal (TSE) in March 2014. The coalition broke after those very representatives suspended PP and its leader, current Vice President Roxanna Baldetti, for up to six months.+
Baldetti responded on two fronts: first, she presented a legal recourse at the Appeals Court in which Escobar was an appointed judge. However, the formal complaint she presented before the International Commission Against Impunity in Guatemala (CICIG), a UN-sponsored technical body, details how PP Congressman Gudy Rivera pressured her to rule in favor of the vice president, in exchange for certainty of her reelection.+
Second, and most importantly, Baldetti scrambled to find a new pact to guarantee the magistrate election would be favorable to her party. She then made an awkward proposal to her former political enemy, LIDER founder and presidential candidate Manuel Baldizón. LIDER had to pull some strings, but could elect four out of 13 magistrates, effectively obtaining veto capabilities to block any trial interposed against them in the next five years.+
In sum, the vice president sold the system of justice in exchange for a simple majority (the remaining nine posts in the court). Independent of the result in the upcoming election of 2015, in which PP and Lider are the main contenders, these strange bedfellows covered themselves with the blanket of impunity.+
None of the deans of professional lawyers, nor the university deans involved in the Postulation Commission, spoke out about any of this. They were complicit in their silence. It took Judge Escobar’s brave voice to mobilize public opinion and embolden the practicing lawyers to take a stance for justice.+
On her call, different judges and magistrates discussed the prospects for annulling the election process carried by the Postulation Commission. On October 3, the civil society group Citizen Action presented the court with the first legal resource against the election.+
On October 7, others followed their steps. Their arguments, presented at the Constitutional Court (CC), is based on the elected magistrates’ lack of compliance with the main requirements to opt into office, as specified by the Judicial Career Law. They were allegedly elected in spite of the lack of requirements due to the convenience this posed for the official and the main opposing parties.+
Another legal device was presented by the Center for the Defense of the Constitution (CEDECON), which made the case for abrogating the election on the basis of a violation of the division of powers. Over 60 judges publicly showed support for repeating the election.+
Given this amount of public scrutiny, the CC needs to resolve this with justice in mind. A provisional ruling points in this direction, but political interests will not give in so smoothly. A hopeful precedent exists: the CC blockaded a similarly corrupt election process for Attorney General five years ago, and Escobar Mejia’s public statement has galvanized public opinion both online and in several demonstrations in front of the CC headquarters in Guatemala City.+
Given that the current elected body of magistrates will favor both of the main incumbent candidates for the following election, what’s at stake is the country’s legal system. It may sink even further in the deep seas of impunity.+
In any case, it will be necessary to have a broader discussion that the creation of the Postulation Commissions didn’t solve: without independently elected magistrates, justice perils at the hand of low politics.+
Luis Eduardo Barrueto is a journalist from Guatemala. He studies in the Erasmus Mundus masters program in journalism, media, and globalization in London, United Kingdom. Follow @lebarrueto.
Originally here:

Update Oct 31 2014

As fallout from this situation, on October 21 the officialism party was poised to lose, not only the congressional presidency but also was in danger of being left out of the congressional directive altogether and congress was poised to name a commission to investigate Gudy Rivera.  All this was avoided when a large group of protestors though to be directed by the officialism party violently blocked opposition congressmen from entering congress. 
Trifulca entre manifestantes, diputados y personal del Congreso deja varios lesionados

On October 29, Gudy Rivera presented his own articles of impeachment as retaliation against Claudia Escobar.
Diputado Gudy Rivera presenta antejuicio contra magistrada 

That same day the congress elects the 2015 directive and congressional president,  backed by the officialism party.
Diputados eligen directiva del 2015 /Congreso_de_la_republica-eleccion-junta_directiva_0_1239476269.html 

On October 30 Claudia Escobar presented her case at the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights
and also spoke at The Center for International Law CEJIL:
Brown bag lunch con la magistrada guatemalteca Claudia Escobar

Other readings

Civil Society, Judges Team Up Against Judicial Corruption in Guatemala

Added Oct. 18, 2014
Guatemala Judge Slams Corrupt Selection Process

Following Outcry, Guatemala Suspends Election of High Court Judges

Voto disedente - Dissenting Vote
Creative Commons License
A #Geoengineering #Climate Issues blog - Geoingeniería by Oscar and Jocelyn Escobar is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.Licencia Creative Commons
A #Geoengineering #Climate Issues blog por Oscar y Jocelyn Escobar se distribuye bajo una Licencia Creative Commons Atribución-NoComercial 4.0 Internacional.